A lot of times I wonder if I don’t love food simply because it’s a vehicle to ingest delicious, delicious condiments, particularly condiments of the vinegary variety. If you were to open my fridge right this very second, and calculate the ratio of sauces:actual food items, your number would be very large. Mustard is one of my all time favourites. Everything from the nuclear yellow French’s prepared mustard (which I’m tempted to each with a spoon), to grainy artisan fancy pants moutard.
I found a recipe for roasted garlic-lemon-honey mustard and I thought “now there’s a first date food just waiting to be prepared”, so off I went. Here’s a concise little PDF of the recipe to help you on your way, or if you refuse to read my meandering commentary:
Cackle Fruit — Hhhhh-hi Hhhhh-honey Mustard (PDF).
Here’s what you’ll need:
Roasted Garlic & Lemon Mustard
INGREDIENTS
- 3/4 cup dry white wine
- 3/4 cup mustard seeds
- 2 – 3 bulbs of garlic
- olive oil
- 1 and 1/4 cup white wine vinegar
- 2 large lemons for both zest (zest first!) and juice (2/3 cup)
- 1/4 cup local honey
- 1/2 tsp Kosher salt
- garlic powder and dry mustard powder, for adjustments (optional)
Apologies for the “grainy” pictures, it’s not my attempt at a terrible food pun, it’s the last dying gasps of my faithful iPhone. I promise it’ll get better! There are basically two main parts to this recipe, which take a bit of time. The first is soaking your mustard seeds, the second is roasting your garlic.
Seemingly Random Tip #1: Do NOT make this recipe within 24 hours of expecting company at your house. Roasting 2-3 full hunks of garlic, mashing it, and blending it makes delicious mustard, but a very garlicky kitchen.
Soaking the mustard seeds can take anywhere from 2 hours to overnight, so if you’re a planner (I’m certainly not) and can predict when you’re going to have the sudden urge to do some canning, combine 1 1/4 cup of dry white wine with 3/4 cups of mustard seeds the day before. I only had yellow mustard seeds, but for a really neat looking grainy mustard, you can blend yellow and brown. Like magic, the mustard seeds will slowly absorb the wine. Let it sit until most of the wine has been soaked up. I’ve found that it’s usually very close by the time you prep, roast, and cool your garlic and get your lids and jars sterilized.

Garlic, pre-roasting.
Start in on the garlic by chopping the pointy top off to expose the individual cloves, and then peel as many layers of the skin off the sides as you can without risking structural integrity. Pop the de-nuded bulbs in an oven-safe dish, drizzle them with just enough olive oil to coat them, and put them in a pre-heated 350F oven. I like a lot of garlic, so I did 3 whole bulbs rather than 2, but you can adjust according to your own taste. Roast it for 45 minutes, have a peek. If it’s gone deliciously dark brown and smells incredibly sexy, it’s good to go. If not, keep roasting in 15 minute increments until it looks like the post-roasting picture above. Take it out of the oven and let it cool on the counter for a while before trying to handle it.
Once it’s cooled enough for you to pick it up, remove each of the cloves and put them in a food processor/blender. I’ve tried the “squeeze them out like they’re toothpaste” method with decent success, but really the easiest, least messy way to get them out is with a fork. Add in 1/2 cup of vinegar and blend the garlic into a smooth paste that smells like heaven. Add in the wine-soaked mustard seeds, 2/3 cup of lemon juice (use fresh lemons and zest them first so that you can use the zest later), 3/4 cup of vinegar and blend to your desired level of graininess. It’s all about consistency here folks, and it’s an individual thing, so make your mustard the way you want it. I love whole grain, so I didn’t mangle the poor seeds until they were unrecognizable, but just enough to bust them up a bit.
Pour your almost-mustard into a saucepan, add in the honey and salt, and simmer over medium heat, stirring constantly until it starts to thicken up into something resembling the consistency of French’s mustard. Stir in the zest from those fresh lemons you juiced earlier and cook for another minute or so. Taste it. If it’s not mustardy enough, you can use some dry mustard powder to spruce it up a bit. If for some bizarre reason it’s not garlicky enough, you can cheat with a bit of garlic powder. Not sweet enough? More honey. I won’t tell.
Once it tastes the way you want, fill your sterilized jars, wipe and lid them, and process them in your boiling water canner for 15 minutes. Remember to take them out at the end without tipping them, and upon cooling you should hear a ‘POP’ as the seal is formed. If your lid doesn’t have an indent in the middle, it didn’t seal properly, so you’ll have to reprocess that particular jar. I followed the recipe, used 3 full garlic bulbs and ended up with 6 x 125 jars of awesome.
Original recipe from Pinterest.











